RatherQuestions Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions
Tap a side, see the live vote, then hit Next for another one.
Would you rather…
Questions about turkey, pie, family traditions and the food coma that follows. Use them to keep the kids' table busy or to start a debate over dessert.
How to use these at Thanksgiving
Hand the kids' table a list and let them quiz the adults, or go round the table between courses. It gives relatives who only see each other once a year something easy to talk about.
In class, use one as the warm-up for the week before the break, or pair a question with a short gratitude-writing prompt.
All thanksgiving would you rather questions
- Would you rather eat only turkey on Thanksgiving or eat only side dishes on Thanksgiving?
- Would you rather have pumpkin pie or have apple pie?
- Would you rather sit at the kids' table forever or sit at the grown-ups' table and stay quiet?
- Would you rather watch the parade or watch the football game?
- Would you rather eat mashed potatoes or eat stuffing?
- Would you rather win the wishbone pull or get the last piece of pie?
- Would you rather cook the whole Thanksgiving dinner or wash all the dishes afterward? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather eat Thanksgiving leftovers for a week or never have leftovers again?
- Would you rather have a turkey the size of a car or have a pie the size of a table?
- Would you rather ride on a parade float or hold the rope for a giant parade balloon?
- Would you rather eat cranberry sauce from a can or eat homemade cranberry sauce?
- Would you rather take a nap after dinner or play a game after dinner?
- Would you rather have Thanksgiving at your house or go to someone else's house for Thanksgiving?
- Would you rather say what you're thankful for in a song or say what you're thankful for in a dance?
- Would you rather eat a turkey leg or eat a turkey sandwich?
- Would you rather have gravy on everything or have butter on everything?
- Would you rather have dessert first or have dessert twice?
- Would you rather have a pet turkey or have a pet pumpkin that talks?
- Would you rather make the pies or make the rolls?
- Would you rather play football in the backyard or go on a family walk?
- Would you rather eat sweet potatoes with marshmallows or eat sweet potatoes without marshmallows?
- Would you rather have a huge family Thanksgiving or have a small cozy Thanksgiving?
- Would you rather be a giant balloon in the parade or be a marching band drummer in the parade?
- Would you rather eat corn on the cob or eat green bean casserole?
- Would you rather set the table or clear the table?
- Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner at breakfast time or have Thanksgiving dinner at midnight?
- Would you rather have whipped cream on your pie or have ice cream on your pie?
- Would you rather make a hand turkey drawing or make a pinecone turkey? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather eat a whole pie by yourself or share one slice with the whole family?
- Would you rather have mac and cheese at Thanksgiving or have pizza at Thanksgiving?
- Would you rather be in charge of the music or be in charge of the games?
- Would you rather smell turkey cooking all day or smell pie baking all day?
- Would you rather have a food fight with mashed potatoes or have a food fight with dinner rolls?
- Would you rather eat dark meat or eat white meat?
- Would you rather go to a Thanksgiving parade in person or watch it on TV in your pajamas?
- Would you rather have a turkey that gobbles every time you laugh or have a pie that sings when you cut it?
- Would you rather eat stuffing with every bite or eat cranberry sauce with every bite?
- Would you rather make placemats for everyone or make name cards for everyone?
- Would you rather have a four-day weekend every month or have one week off every fall?
- Would you rather have rolls that never run out or have gravy that never runs out?
- Would you rather be the one who carves the turkey or be the one who says the thankful speech?
- Would you rather have pecan pie or have chocolate pie?
- Would you rather watch a Thanksgiving movie or play a Thanksgiving board game? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather eat with a fork that's too big or eat with a spoon that's too small? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather have a leaf pile as tall as your house or have a pumpkin as big as your bed?
- Would you rather make turkey-shaped cookies or make pie-shaped cupcakes?
- Would you rather eat dinner by candlelight or eat dinner outside under the stars?
- Would you rather taste every dish on the table or only eat your three favorites?
- Would you rather make a gratitude jar or write thank-you notes to friends?
- Would you rather have a turkey costume or have a pumpkin pie costume?
- Would you rather play tag in the leaves or build a fort out of hay bales?
- Would you rather eat pie for breakfast the next day or eat a turkey sandwich for breakfast the next day?
- Would you rather have a Thanksgiving with only desserts or have a Thanksgiving with only potatoes?
- Would you rather help make the gravy or help mash the potatoes?
- Would you rather be the first to eat or be the last to finish?
- Would you rather have your family play charades or have your family play a big trivia game?
- Would you rather go on a hayride or go apple picking?
- Would you rather have a turkey that's too dry or have a pie with a soggy crust?
- Would you rather eat a meal with 20 different dishes or eat a meal with one perfect dish? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather be thankful out loud or write what you're thankful for on a leaf?
How to play
Read a question out loud and give everyone five seconds to pick a side. No "neither," no "both." Then go around the group and have each person defend their answer.
Playing solo? Tap your answer above to see how everyone else voted, then hit Next. Each question has its own page with its live results, so you can send the tough ones to friends.
Questions people ask
What are good thanksgiving would you rather questions?
A few favorites: "Would you rather eat only turkey on Thanksgiving or eat only side dishes on Thanksgiving?" "Would you rather have pumpkin pie or have apple pie?" "Would you rather sit at the kids' table forever or sit at the grown-ups' table and stay quiet?" The full list is above, and every question links to its live vote results.
How do you play would you rather?
One person reads a question, everyone picks a side, then each player explains their choice. On this page, tap an answer to vote and see the live split, then hit Next for another question.
Are these questions appropriate for kids?
Yes. Every question on this page is reviewed by a person and kept kid-friendly: silly and gross-out is fine, but nothing violent and nothing scarier than a jack-o'-lantern.