Extreme Would You Rather Questions
Tap a side, see the live vote, then hit Next for another one.
Would you rather…
Over-the-top choices with sky-high stakes: live on Mars or under the sea, give up the internet or give up sleep. Every option is wild, and none of them is easy.
How to use extreme questions
These are built for groups that have already burned through the easy questions. Read one out, give everyone ten seconds, and make each person commit with no "it depends."
For a party game, have the minority side make the case for their choice; if they win anyone over, they score a point. They are dramatic, but never gory or inappropriate, so they work for teens and family game night as well as adults.
All extreme would you rather questions
- Would you rather live on Mars forever or live under the ocean forever? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather give up the internet for five years or give up sleeping in a bed for five years?
- Would you rather climb Mount Everest or swim across the English Channel?
- Would you rather be stranded on a desert island alone or be stranded in Antarctica with a group?
- Would you rather never eat sugar again or never eat anything cooked again?
- Would you rather go a year without talking or go a year without your phone?
- Would you rather be able to control the weather or be able to control gravity?
- Would you rather spend a night alone in a haunted castle or spend a week alone in a cabin in the woods?
- Would you rather eat a cricket every day for a year or eat a spoonful of hot sauce every day for a year?
- Would you rather live in a world with no electricity or live in a world with no running water?
- Would you rather jump out of a plane or cage dive with great white sharks?
- Would you rather be stuck in an elevator for a whole day or be stuck at the top of a roller coaster for an hour?
- Would you rather lose all your money or lose all your memories of the last five years?
- Would you rather explore outer space alone or explore the deep ocean alone?
- Would you rather have to sprint everywhere you go or have to crawl everywhere you go? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather live in a tiny house with ten people or live in a mansion completely alone?
- Would you rather go on a one-way mission to a new planet or never leave your hometown again?
- Would you rather go a month without showering or go a week without brushing your teeth?
- Would you rather wear a full suit of armor every day or wear a clown costume every day?
- Would you rather eat only ice cream for a year or never eat ice cream again?
- Would you rather walk across the United States or bike across Europe?
- Would you rather go ten years without music or go ten years without seeing the sun?
- Would you rather be famous worldwide with no privacy or be unknown with complete privacy?
- Would you rather be able to hold your breath for an hour or be able to go a week without sleep?
- Would you rather live 200 years in the past or live 200 years in the future?
- Would you rather skydive from the edge of space or dive to the deepest point of the ocean?
- Would you rather fall asleep for 50 years or stay awake for a whole week?
- Would you rather have fingers as long as your legs or have legs as short as your fingers?
- Would you rather talk in a robot voice for a month or talk in a cartoon voice for a month?
- Would you rather live on a sailboat forever or live in a treehouse forever?
- Would you rather lose the internet worldwide for a month or lose electricity in your town for a month?
- Would you rather run a marathon with no training or give a speech in a packed stadium with no notes?
- Would you rather have a pet tiger or have a pet crocodile?
- Would you rather walk a tightrope across the Grand Canyon or bungee jump off the tallest bridge in the world?
- Would you rather eat the world's spiciest pepper or eat the world's sourest candy every day for a week?
- Would you rather switch lives with a stranger for a year or switch bodies with your best friend for a month?
- Would you rather travel the world for free but never return home or stay home forever and get paid a fortune?
- Would you rather be the first person to walk on Mars or be the first person to meet aliens?
- Would you rather give up your phone forever or give up your car forever?
- Would you rather spend a year at the South Pole or spend a year in the Sahara Desert?
- Would you rather be three feet tall or be nine feet tall?
- Would you rather live in a glass house or live in a house with no windows?
- Would you rather ride the world's tallest roller coaster 100 times in a row or ride a rocket into orbit once?
- Would you rather never use a screen again or never read again?
- Would you rather speak only in song lyrics or speak only in movie quotes?
- Would you rather sleep in a hammock hanging over a canyon or sleep in an underwater hotel room?
- Would you rather eat sushi from a gas station or eat a meal cooked by a toddler?
- Would you rather walk everywhere for the rest of your life or ride a unicycle everywhere for the rest of your life?
- Would you rather lose your sense of humor or lose your sense of direction?
- Would you rather be trapped inside a video game or be trapped inside a cartoon?
- Would you rather spend every night in a museum after closing or spend every night in an amusement park after closing?
- Would you rather have a third arm or have a third eye?
- Would you rather survive a week on ramen noodles or survive a week on canned beans?
- Would you rather win the lottery but spend it all in a week or earn an average salary forever?
- Would you rather give up all social media forever or give up all streaming forever?
- Would you rather move to a country where you don't speak the language or move to a remote island with no neighbors?
- Would you rather wear wet socks all day or wear a sweater in a heat wave all day?
- Would you rather live in a world without cheese or live in a world without chocolate?
- Would you rather live through an ice age or live through a never-ending heat wave?
- Would you rather spend a week living in a cave or spend a week living in a submarine?
How to play
Read a question out loud and give everyone five seconds to pick a side. No "neither," no "both." Then go around the group and have each person defend their answer.
Playing solo? Tap your answer above to see how everyone else voted, then hit Next. Each question has its own page with its live results, so you can send the tough ones to friends.
Questions people ask
What are good extreme would you rather questions?
A few favorites: "Would you rather live on Mars forever or live under the ocean forever?" "Would you rather give up the internet for five years or give up sleeping in a bed for five years?" "Would you rather climb Mount Everest or swim across the English Channel?" The full list is above, and every question links to its live vote results.
How do you play would you rather?
One person reads a question, everyone picks a side, then each player explains their choice. On this page, tap an answer to vote and see the live split, then hit Next for another question.