RatherQuestions Halloween Would You Rather Questions
Tap a side, see the live vote, then hit Next for another one.
Would you rather…
Spooky-but-not-scary choices about costumes, candy, haunted houses and monsters. They suit classroom parties, trick-or-treat walks and Halloween game nights.
How to use these for Halloween
For a classroom Halloween party, read a question and have kids move to the side of the room for their answer, or hold up a candy-corn sign for A and a pumpkin sign for B. It works as a calm-down game between party activities.
At home, use them on the walk between trick-or-treat stops, while carving pumpkins or at a Halloween sleepover. They are spooky-silly rather than scary, so they suit younger kids too.
All halloween would you rather questions
- Would you rather trick-or-treat in a blizzard or trick-or-treat in a heat wave?
- Would you rather only get candy corn or only get raisins?
- Would you rather wear the same costume every Halloween or never be allowed to wear a costume again? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather live in a haunted house or live next door to a haunted house?
- Would you rather be a vampire who can't stand garlic or be a werewolf who's allergic to the moon?
- Would you rather carve 100 pumpkins or eat 100 pieces of candy corn?
- Would you rather have a pet black cat or have a pet bat? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather be able to turn invisible on Halloween or be able to fly on Halloween? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather go through the scariest haunted house in the world or watch the scariest movie in the world?
- Would you rather have a costume that glows in the dark or have a costume that makes spooky sounds?
- Would you rather trade all your candy for one giant chocolate bar or keep your whole bag of mixed candy?
- Would you rather be a friendly ghost or be a grumpy witch?
- Would you rather hand out candy at home or go trick-or-treating?
- Would you rather only eat chocolate candy or only eat sour candy?
- Would you rather spend the night in a pumpkin patch or spend the night in a corn maze?
- Would you rather have a broomstick that flies or have a cauldron that makes any food? 0% / 100% · 2 votes
- Would you rather wear a costume made entirely of candy wrappers or wear a costume made entirely of leaves?
- Would you rather meet a real mummy or meet a real zombie?
- Would you rather have Halloween twice a year or have your birthday twice a year?
- Would you rather bob for apples or do a pie-eating contest?
- Would you rather be a skeleton who can't stop dancing or be a ghost who can't stop giggling? 100% / 0% · 2 votes
- Would you rather get a full-size candy bar from every house or get to visit twice as many houses?
- Would you rather live in a castle full of bats or live in a cabin full of spiders? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather have glow-in-the-dark teeth or have glow-in-the-dark hair?
- Would you rather dress up as your teacher or have your teacher dress up as you?
- Would you rather make a jack-o'-lantern that talks or make a scarecrow that walks?
- Would you rather eat a candy apple or eat a caramel apple?
- Would you rather win the costume contest or win the pumpkin carving contest?
- Would you rather be followed by a friendly ghost all day or be followed by a talking black cat all day?
- Would you rather have a werewolf as a best friend or have a vampire as a best friend? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather trick-or-treat with your family or trick-or-treat with your friends? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather have a spooky laugh you can't control or have a cackle that echoes everywhere?
- Would you rather find a secret room in a haunted house or find a hidden treasure in a graveyard? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather only be able to whisper on Halloween or only be able to howl on Halloween?
- Would you rather wear a mask that never comes off for a day or wear a cape that never comes off for a week?
- Would you rather have a pumpkin for a head for a day or have a broomstick for a leg for a day?
- Would you rather get a costume that's too big or get a costume that's too small? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather eat a worm-shaped gummy or eat an eyeball-shaped gumball?
- Would you rather have a haunted toy that moves at night or have a haunted mirror that talks back? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather be the scariest person on the block or be the funniest costume on the block?
- Would you rather have a pet spider the size of a dog or have a pet dog the size of a spider? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather throw a Halloween party or go to a Halloween party?
- Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or be able to see in the dark?
- Would you rather sleep in a coffin for a night or sleep in a treehouse full of owls? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather eat pumpkin pie every day or eat pumpkin bread every day?
- Would you rather have a costume that changes every hour or have one perfect costume all night? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather be stuck in a spider web or be stuck in a pile of slime?
- Would you rather have every house give out toothbrushes or have every house give out pennies?
- Would you rather ride a ghost train or ride a haunted hayride? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather be a witch with a forgetful spellbook or be a wizard with a wobbly wand?
- Would you rather decorate your house with 1000 pumpkins or decorate your house with 1000 fake spiders?
- Would you rather have a scary voice or have a scary face?
- Would you rather get lost in a corn maze or get locked in a pumpkin patch?
- Would you rather turn into a bat at night or turn into a black cat at night?
- Would you rather eat all your candy on Halloween night or make your candy last until Christmas? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather have a group costume with your friends or have a solo costume nobody else has? 0% / 100% · 1 votes
- Would you rather hear a creaky door every time you sit down or hear a ghostly boo every time you sneeze?
- Would you rather go trick-or-treating in a castle or go trick-or-treating on a spaceship?
- Would you rather be a monster under the bed or be a monster in the closet? 100% / 0% · 1 votes
- Would you rather have a jack-o'-lantern that never goes out or have a candy bowl that never runs empty?
How to play
Read a question out loud and give everyone five seconds to pick a side. No "neither," no "both." Then go around the group and have each person defend their answer.
Playing solo? Tap your answer above to see how everyone else voted, then hit Next. Each question has its own page with its live results, so you can send the tough ones to friends.
Questions people ask
What are good halloween would you rather questions?
A few favorites: "Would you rather trick-or-treat in a blizzard or trick-or-treat in a heat wave?" "Would you rather only get candy corn or only get raisins?" "Would you rather wear the same costume every Halloween or never be allowed to wear a costume again?" The full list is above, and every question links to its live vote results.
How do you play would you rather?
One person reads a question, everyone picks a side, then each player explains their choice. On this page, tap an answer to vote and see the live split, then hit Next for another question.
Are these questions appropriate for kids?
Yes. Every question on this page is reviewed by a person and kept kid-friendly: silly and gross-out is fine, but nothing violent and nothing scarier than a jack-o'-lantern.